News

Opinion: In the age of Trump, America should take a page from Machiavelli

Ever since Donald Trump was re-elected, I have been haunted by a passage in Machiavelli’s “The Prince.”

“Whoever becomes the master of a city accustomed to freedom, and does not destroy it, may expect to be destroyed himself; because, when there is a rebellion, such a city justifies itself by calling on the name of liberty and its ancient institutions, never forgotten despite the passing of time and the benefits received from the new ruler.”

Trump intuitively grasps this. Now “master of a city accustomed to freedom,” he is determined to destroy it before it destroys him.

The president-elect’s Cabinet nominations make this clear. They include individuals who will hunt down immigrants with the goal of expelling them (by the millions), others who will politicize the military and compromise U.S. intelligence, still others who will gut and weaponize the Department of Justice, and an entitled anti-vaxxer who will undercut many of the agencies that protect our health. In addition, his energy policies will exacerbate rather than mitigate the ravages of climate change.

Finally, Trump’s creation of a new office — the Department of Government Efficiency, led by two untethered billionaires — will shred scores of programs on which the American people rely.

In short, we are watching an assault on American democracy. Our republic is eroding before our eyes. And we have been complicit.

The Senate could have convicted Trump for his efforts to overturn the will of the people in the 2020 election but declined to do so. The Department of Justice could have moved far more quickly to hold him accountable for both this crime and his removal of top-secret documents from the White House when he retreated to Mar-a-Lago in 2021. The Democratic Party could have held a real primary to select a viable candidate to oppose Trump in this year’s election.

Over and over again, we have faltered. And now it is not clear we will have the ability to bring an end to Trump’s relentless attack on our republic — an attack that is happening in plain daylight.

But Machiavelli’s text offers a glimmer of hope. Machiavelli, after all, lived at a similar inflection point in history. Florence, one of the great Renaissance republics, was being transformed into a monarchy even at the moment he was writing. But Machiavelli was not crafting, as many believe, a handbook for princes. To the contrary, throughout the text, he makes it clear that he believes the people can fight to preserve their freedoms.

On this front, it is the second half of the sentence above that matters. Machiavelli was calling on Florentines to remember their freedoms. But we too, some 500 years later, are a people “accustomed to freedom” — and to preserve our freedoms we have the power of “calling upon on the nature of liberty and [our] ancient institutions.”

It is easy to recognize the liberties we are losing and will continue to lose if Trump has his way and is unchecked — as seems likely — by an obsequious Congress. It is urgent that we draw on our own memories of what the U.S., for all its flaws, has been.

We must remember that in our country, before Trump 2.0, the U.S. Senate exercised the right of “advice and consent” when it came to presidential appointments; earlier, too, the president did not enjoy blanket immunity; the office of attorney general was independent of presidential whim; women had the right to control their own bodies; immigrants could not be deported without a hearing; public health policy was determined by science; the right to vote was protected; and there was some progress (though not enough) in the pivot to renewable forms of energy.

Trump knows we have these memories. This is why, driven by his own paranoia, he is seeking to destroy our liberties. He knows that the very institutions he is now attacking (the Justice Department, the Pentagon, the Senate) have the potential to hold him in check. We have to fight back.

“The Prince” is a timely read right now. But Machiavelli understood that reading alone is not enough. What Machiavelli was seeking was an informed people who would fight for their freedoms. More than two centuries later, at the dawn of the age of democratic revolutions, the Enlightenment philosopher Jean-Jacques Rousseau understood this. In “The Social Contract” he observed that Machiavelli, “under the pretense of instructing kings … has taught important lessons to the people. Machiavelli’s ‘Prince’ is a handbook for republicans.”

At the core of this handbook is the idea of liberty. Trump has every reason to fear that the American people, not only remembering but also cherishing this idea, will do everything they can to preserve the institutions that protect their freedoms.

Indeed, since his programs involve ᵴtriƥping away freedoms from nearly all Americans, it is likely that both those who supported him and those who opposed him will join together in this fight.

Related Posts

Melania Trump sues Hunter Biden for over $US1 billion over ‘defamatory’ Epstein comments

Melania Trump has demanded Hunter Biden “retract the false, defamatory, and lewd” statements he made about her that referenced her relationship with Jeffrey Epstein, according to Fox News. Lawyers…

BBC News reported: 30 minutes ago! Trump orders Whoopi Goldberg deported from the US — “The View” host fires back: He knew I had secrets that could hurt the midterm elections

President Trump’s Demand for Whoopi Goldberg’s Departure Sparks Firestorm. In a stunning development, President Donald Trump issued a provocative statement today at a White House press conference, demanding…

BREAKING NEWS: 30 minutes ago, Aidan Hutchinson sends 5-word message to NFL that shocks Roger Goodell, after Detroit Lions fined $50 million for refusing to post Pride Month message on social media…

The hot news has just been released from the National Rugby Federation (NFL) when Aidan Hutchinson, the defensive star of the Detroit Lions team, sent a brief message…

“YOU DEFAMED ME ON LIVE TV — NOW PAY THE PRICE!” — Country music powerhouse Carrie Underwood has filed a $50 million lawsuit against *The View* and Whoopi Goldberg, accusing them of “vicious, calculated defamation” after Whoopi Goldberg insulted Carrie Underwood live on air, causing her to lose multiple contracts and damaging her reputation

Carrie Underwood, one of country music’s most celebrated artists, has taken legal action against The View and its co-host Whoopi Goldberg, filing a staggering $50 million lawsuit over what she…

BREAKING: Texas has APPROVED a new redistricting map that adds five Republican seats, removes five Democrat seats, and ELIMINATES Jasmine Crockett’s position

Texas has recently approved a controversial new redistricting map that significantly alters the state’s political landscape. The decision, finalized by the Texas legislature, introduces changes that are set…

BREAKING: U.S. Attorney Jeanine Pirro will personally investigate “Shifty” Adam Schiff. President Trump has just unleashed the “perfect weapon.” The very first target of U.S. Attorney Jeanine Pirro is none other than Adam Schiff. This is the same Schiff who LIED to the American people, smeared President Trump, and pushed FAKE investigations for years

In a stunning turn of events that has captured national attention, U.S. Attorney Jeanine Pirro is set to personally lead an investigation into Representative Adam Schiff, a figure…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *